Game Day Sweets

The easiest way to feel like a winner while watching the Super Bowl LVII (Sunday, February 11, 2024) is to make sure your dessert defensive line is stacked. That’s why, on top of our plans for wings, the dips, and sliders, we’re heading for a touchdown with some winning dessert recipes, ofc! Though maybe not the first thing that comes to mind when you think Super Bowl, we’re all about offering a little something sweet to help celebrate the wins (or soothe the stress of losing!).

Super Bowl desserts are the perfect options, whether you’re looking for Instagram-worthy football-shaped treats, portable bites that don’t require a plate, or shareable dishes your whole crowd can dive into.

It’s gotta be said: Super Bowl parties can get a little… messy. Many of the classic apps are practically known for being extra saucy and unwieldy—and that’s one of the reasons we love ’em! If this stresses you out more than any penalty or a fumble, try one of the bars, cookies, or bites we included on this list just for you.

Hot tip: Cut them smaller so they’re easier to eat in fewer bites (less crumbs!).


Peanut Butter Pretzel Butterscotch Blondies

Love a salty-sweet dessert? Prepare to meet your new obsession. Studded with pretzels and butterscotch chips, these rich peanut butter blondies rival any brownie or magic bar out there.

Get the Peanut Butter Pretzel Butterscotch Blondies recipe.


Football-Shaped Cookies

These sugar cookies are so easy to design, even the kids can get in on it—turn it into a game day activity the whole fam can do together! Hot tip: Freeze your cut-out cookie dough for 10 minutes before baking to ensure they hold their adorable football shape.

Get the Football Cookies recipe.


Cannoli Chips & Dip

Delicious, creamy Cannoli Dip is the perfect sweet treat for your next get together. Made with just 5 ingredients, this delicious dip is better than classic Cannolis and SO much easier! The perfect no bake dessert!

Get the Cannoli Chips & Dip recipe.


Millionaire’s Shortbread

Everyone can be a millionaire during the Super Bowl! Simply make these delicious treats with layers of shortbread cookies, homemade caramel, and dark chocolate ganache. Add a sprinkle of flaky salt on top for contrast.

Get the Millionaire’s Shortbread recipe.


Cowboy Cookies

The biggest football game of the year deserves some big desserts. We’re talking about loaded chocolate chip cookies filled with hearty mix-ins like oats, pecans, and coconut.

Get the Cowboy Cookies recipe.


Salted Pecan Caramel Corn

For a sweet and salty snack, this homemade caramel corn is great for munching on. We especially love the bites of pecans sprinkled throughout for added crunch!

Get the Salted Pecan Caramel Corn recipe.


Guinness Brownies

Brownies and beer? It’s an unexpectedly great combo and apt for game day. The dark, coffee-scented Guinness is a delightful flavor pairing with chocolate, intensifying the rich, fudgy flavor of these brownies.

Get the Guinness Brownies recipe.


Coca-Cola Cake

This dessert looks like a party in itself! The retro darling uses Coca-Cola in the cake batter to make it incredibly light and tender. Three cheers for vintage fun!

Get the Coca-Cola Cake recipe.


Salted Pretzel Chocolate Chip Cookie Snickers Bar

There’s so much to love about these cookie bars. They have a cookie base, a caramel center, and a hard chocolate topping.

Get the Chocolate Chip Cookie Snickers Bar recipe at Half Baked Harvest.

Quick Links

Contact Us

Join our mailing list

Get the latest news, updates and freebies

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *